A MUST READ FOR ALL NEW INDIAN ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICE (IAS) OFFICER EXAMINATION CANDIDATES
Sunday, October 11, 2015
THE CALCUTTA QURAN PETITION AN EYE OPENING BOOK BY THE LATE SITA RAM GOEL
ISLAM WITHOUT ILLUSIONS
Theory and practice explained
The Calcutta Quran Petition
Sita Ram Goel
New Delhi, Voice of India, 1999, 3rd edition
325 + xvi pages, Rs 150 (PB)
Reviewed by Dr. N.S. Rajaram
The average educated person today, anywhere in the world, is likely to be
both confused and frightened by Islam. On the one hand, it is supposed to be a
religion of peace that preaches equality and justice for all, while on the other, it
is hardly possible to escape the sight of the most unspeakable acts of violence
being committed by individuals and groups in its name.
To make the situation more confusing, there is no shortage of 'experts' - Eastern and Western - who tell us that Islamic terror is an aberration that has nothing to do with the 'true' Islam.
It is fair to say that a majority of the people in the world has swallowed this
explanation while remaining ambivalent about Muslims and their behavior.
In the book under review, Sita Ram Goel, one of the world's most incisive students
of Islam, blows away this confusion by giving an unwarnished, scholarly yet
highly readable account of the theory and practice of Islam. By a detailed
analysis of its scripture and history, he explodes the charade that Islamic terror
can somehow be separated from its teachings. In the process, the prolific and
erudite Mr. Goel has probably written his masterpiece.
To return to the confused state of knowledge about Islam, there has long been a need - more urgent today than ever before - for a work that can explain the theory and practice of Islam for the average reader. This void is now effectively filled by the book under review - 'The Calcutta Quran Petition' by Sita Ram Goel. His pluralistic Hindu background gives him a distinct advantage over his Western counterparts, who, despite their best efforts, cannot entirely break free of the shackles of their exclusivist Judeo-Christian heritage that springs from the same soil as Islam. Goel on the other hand looks at Islam as a complete outsider, disregarding its pious claims. If there is one book on Islam that a concerned person should read, it is his 'The Calcutta Quran Petition'. The book could with equal justice be titled 'Islam for Nonbelievers: Its scripture, history and practice'. The reason for the unusual title is historical. On 29 March 1985, one Chandmal Chopra filed a writ petition in the Calcutta High Court seeking a ban on the Quran under Sections 153A and 295A of the Indian Penal Code because it "incites violence, disturbs public tranquility, promotes, on the ground of religion, feelings of enmity, hatred and ill-will between different religious groups.
religious communities, and insults other religions or religious beliefs of other
religious communities of India." The Calcutta High Court disallowed the
petition, but the issues raised by it remain relevant, especially now when the
need to understand the causes of terror in the name of Islam is greater than ever.
More significantly for the present discussion, it led Sita Ram Goel to write the
volume under review. The sordid details of the case in question would probably
be of little interest to the average reader today though they shed much light on
the ignoble conduct of the Governments of India and West Bengal in the face of
real or perceived Muslim threats. Out of a total of 345 pages, the author devotes
no less than 230 pages to a general discussion of Islam that has little directly to
do with the Calcutta Petition. These pages, covering Chapters 2 through 10,
constitute for all practical purposes an independent manual on Islam, beginning
with the message of the Quran. This is what is reviewed here.
Quran and the Hadis
The first point about the Quran is that it does not stand alone. The Suras
(verses) of the Quran were created in specific situations arising out of specific
military, political and sometimes personal needs. They invariably reflect the
convenience of the Prophet who found it expedient to invoke Allah as authority
to have his own way with his people. Seeing this, his favorite wife A'sha once
observed, "I find that Allah is prompt to proclaim commandments in accordance
with your desire." This means that the context in which a Sura was created is
all-important. Taking Quranic passages out of context can lead to outlandish
interpretations like Sir Abdullah Suhrawardy's Sayings of Muhammad, which
Mahatma Gandhi hailed in his Foreword as among the "treasures of mankind."
The all-important context for interpreting the Suras of the Quran is provided
by the Hadis. They may be described as the record of the activities of the
Prophet. They are so detailed, that it is possible to obtain a more or less
complete picture of the private and public life of the Prophet. It may fairly be
said that the Hadis rather than Quran form the basis for Islam, for without them
the Quran becomes virtually incomprehensible. As Goel makes clear (Chapter
3) there is practically no difference between Allah and the Prophet; Allah does
at the Prophet's bidding. This made the great Maharshi Dayananda Saraswati
observe, "Allah is the Prophet's domestic servant." As Goel explains, this makes
the Quran (the 'Word of Allah') and the Hadis ('Acts of Muhammad')
In other words, the Hadis describe the Quran in action, meaning the acts of
the Prophet. These in turn became the model of behavior to be emulated, for
every true Muslim from the highest to the lowest. As Goel observes: "It is this
fixed and frozen image of the Prophet which is meant when a Muslim proclaims
his Din (fundamental faith). In fact the Prophet produced a 'revelation' (33.21)
presenting himself as the perfect model for those who look forward (with hope)
for the Day of Judgement. For a pious Muslim, human life is best lived when it
conforms to Muhammad's conduct even in minor matters such as defecating... ,
cutting one's beard to a specific size and so on. Islam leaves no room at all for
individual initiative or judgment...
In case of doubt, a pious Muslim must go to a mufti (juriconsultant) and
obtain a fatwa [ruling] about how the Prophet would have conducted himself in
a situation which, according to all sources, the Prophet is not known to have
faced." Needless to say, this is not a climate conducive to progress.
This has a sinister side with far-reaching implications. Since the later part of
the Prophet's career is full of war and bloodshed in the name of Allah, religious
war or Jihad is seen as the highest goal of Islam. What the world is faced today -
from Kashmir to Kosovo (and now West Asia and Syria, pushing into Euurope)
- is Jihad or religious war to bring the whole world under the sway of Islam.
This reality cannot be wished away as is done by liberal academics in East and
West, by giving an abstract interpretation of Jihad. As Walter Laquer, an
American expert on terrorism observed, "Many interpreters of jihad in the
Muslim world, and an equal number in the West, have explained that jihad has a
double meaning: it stands for jihad bi al saif (holy war by means of the sword)
and also for jihad al nafs (literally, struggle for one's soul against one's own base
instinct). Both interpretations are true, but Islamic militants have rejected the
spiritual explanation as dangerous heresy. ...The Taliban in Afghanistan and
many militants (especially ISIS today) are not impressed by the speeches and
writings of more moderate exegetists about the 'poverty of fanaticism' and the
'spiritual mission of Islam,' and this fact is what matters..."
The fact of the matter is that influential Muslim leaders see the violent
version of Jihad as the only valid one. Jihad to them is "the most glorious word
in the vocabulary of Islam," and by this they don't mean striving for inner
perfection. Goel explains this vital fact with clarity and thoroughness with
profuse illustrations from the history and scripture of Islam. As he points out,
the Quran studied alongside the Hadis is a nothing but a manual on Jihad - or
religious war. Just as the Prophet became the model for Muslim behavior, his
blood soaked career became the model for a succession of Muslim leaders down
to the present.
While the Hadis are indispensable for understanding Islam, they present a
bewildering mass of detail to the uninitiated. In Chapter 4 ('The Prophet Sets the
Pattern'), the author takes the reader through the Prophet's career by presenting a
systematic picture of the historical background and the key events. He describes
also two interesting episodes that are not widely known: the Prophet's invitation,
in a time of distress, to the Christian Abyssinians to invade Mecca, claiming that
his teachings were no different from theirs; and the famous 'Satanic verses'
inspired by the need to regain the support of the Meccans. In Chapter 5 ('The
Orthodox Exposition of Jihad'), the author produces evidence from primary
sources to demolish the claim of modern apologists that Jihad has - or ever had -
a spiritual meaning. This 'spiritual' interpretation is exhumed only when they
feel insecure - as in India today, or when faced with powerful opponents like the
United States - to be buried again when conditions turn favorable.
Chapter 6 ('Jihad in India's History') may be read as a practical
demonstration of Islam in action. It is to be hoped that every policymaker in
India as well as the West will read this capsule account of the 'bloodiest story in
history' - as Will Durant called it - and learn its lessons. Indians in particular
must face this historical truth and not seek escape in fantasies written by